Trade vs human rights

Business is anything but usual with Saudi Arabia

Article reuse Print this story
Foreign Affairs  
Demonstrators in Qatif demand the release of political prisonersImage Caption:

Demonstrators in Qatif demand the release of political prisoners (Reuters)

by Peter Siegenthaler, swissinfo.ch

Saudi Arabia, a key player in the conflict in Syria, is an important Swiss trade partner but it regularly makes headlines due to human rights violations. Is conducting business with the desert state complicity, or another way of bringing about change?

“In Saudi Arabia two human rights advocates were sentenced to stiff jail sentences. . . . The true reason for the high penalty is that the reformers spoke out in favour of change and on behalf of political prisoners,” Zurich’s Neue Zürcher Zeitung reported in March.
 
"An Islamic cleric rapes his five-year-old daughter and beats her to death.” Although he confessed to the crime, he remains a free man in Saudi Arabia, the free newspaper 20 Minuten reported in February.
 
“A young Sri Lankan housekeeper in Saudi Arabia was beheaded after being accused of killing her employer’s baby,” news agencies reported in January. Human Rights Watch called the execution “callous disregard for basic humanity and international obligations”.
 
Human rights organisations repeatedly denounce Saudi Arabia on the basis of blatant violations of human rights. Amnesty International lists, among other things, “detention without charge or trial”, “imprisonment of nonviolent political opponents”, and “suppression of freedom of expression and religion”.

Atypically Saudi

Haifaa al-Mansour, a woman’s voice from Arabia

Wadjda wants a bike, but Saudi girls aren't supposed to ride

Saudi filmmaker Haifaa al-Mansour has won worldwide acclaim for her first feature film, Wadjda, filmed in her home country. Al-Mansour, who has traded her veil for jeans, has cultivated a style that allows her to make strong statements with gentility.  [...]

Economic and strategic interests

In spite of this, government and industry representatives from around the world, many of them Swiss, continue to do business with Saudi Arabia.
 
“A business is not an accomplice” says Jan Atteslander of the Swiss Business Federation, Economiesuisse, “as long as it follows the guidelines of the OECD or the guiding principles of John Ruggie.”
 
Until 2011, Ruggie was the special representative of the United Nations Secretary General on the topic of “Responsibilities of transnational corporations”. His work had the effect of more clearly defining and limiting the division of roles of states and companies. 
 
“With trade and investment a country opens itself not only economically, but on other levels as well,” says the Economiesuisse representative. The exchange of ideas and value systems can create new perspectives domestically and is why isolated dictatorships like North Korea suffer economically. 
 
When speaking of the human rights violations cited above, Atteslander refers to a Spiegel Online article.
 
The German news magazine reported that “against the resistance of conservatives, the royal house has been taking small steps towards giving women more rights. In Riyadh, under the leadership of a royal foundation, the first campaign against domestic violence was launched.”
 
Saudi Arabia, Atteslander argues, also plays an important strategic role in the Middle East.
 
“However tentative they may be, the country launched reforms a few years ago,” he adds. “Saudi Arabia also is active in searching for a solution to the conflicts in Syria and provides a huge amount of humanitarian aid. It’s a stabilising factor in a geopolitical powder keg.”
  
But anyone who trades with Saudi Arabia without starting a dialogue on human rights can be regarded as an accomplice reckons Geri Müller, a Green parliamentarian who serves on the House of Representative’s foreign affairs committee. This dialogue rarely takes place, he believes. “These days Switzerland doesn’t even try,” he adds.
  
The State Secretariat for Economic Affairs doesn’t officially have a position on such problems, leaving it to  the foreign ministry, which simply reports that it “regularly raises the issue of human rights in Saudi Arabia when in contact with the Saudi government”–most recently in the context of the ‘political discussions’ which took place last March in Bern.

Readers react

swissinfo.ch polled Saudi readers via social media about how Saudi Arabia’s human rights record is viewed in the context of its longstanding trade relationships with the West.
 
"Isolating or boycotting the Kingdom is not the solution and would have negative consequences. This method didn’t work with North Korea despite the fact that it’s a poor country. Saudi Arabia is a wealthy country that’s a member of the G20."

“The era of protectorates and conditional trading is long gone. Saudi Arabia can find other commercial partners no problem, like China, Brazil or Turkey. Western countries are the ones doing all they can to develop trade relationships with the Gulf states, all while maintaining fierce competition with China and other countries.”

"Western countries should stop basing business decisions on human rights issues because they don’t respect those rights (racial discrimination, xenophobia) at home."

"For the Western world, business interests take precedent over morals and principles. The proof is what’s currently happening in Syria, in Myanmar and the continued collaboration between Western countries and Russia despite their rigged elections and lack of press freedom. And why don’t they stop trading with China, the largest trading partner of the EU and the US?"
 
"The United States is still using capital punishment and violating detainees’ rights at Guantanamo. Why don’t you stop all commercial activities with them?"

"Conditions were illusory"

As long as the US and Europe are allied with Saudi Arabia and other regional monarchies for economic (oil) and strategic (bulwark against Iran) reasons, Switzerland will not demand alone a human rights dialogue, argues Müller. "The kingdom, which doesn’t depend on Switzerland, could cancel economic relations," he says.
 
"Or it could exploit the dialogue with Switzerland as a pretext for the observance of human rights without anything changing within the justice system. This is a fundamental part of Saudi society."
 
Compared to the west, Saudi Arabia likes to present itself as a modern state. Economically, the country can keep up with leading Western nations.
 
But little is changing on a socio-political level. Wahhabi religious scholars still define what is allowed and forbidden. (See information box.)
 
The "Freedom House” institute, which measures the degree of democracy and freedom in any given nation, awarded the Saudi state its lowest ranking–“not free”–in the political rights category.

Seemingly modern

Saudi Arabia has admitted to financing the Syrian opposition. But its political and strategic role is controversial among Middle East analysts, with many doubting the monarchy is interested in developing more democratic structures.
 
Müller also notes the sharp contrast between Saudi Arabia’s modern exterior and its archaic social structures. He doubts that trade with the West can contribute to the promotion of rule of law.
 
“For decades, the Saudi nobility has been on the move in the Western world; they’re familiar with our customs and mores," he points out.

(Adapted from German by Jeannie Wurz and Susan Vogel-Misicka)

 
4 comments
Comments cannot be shown for the time being