The Swiss National Bank would hold a monopoly in granting loans if the so called Sovereign Money initiative were approved by voters
Keystone
The government has come out against two separate proposals to put Swiss law above international law and to reform the monetary system, giving the central bank the exclusive right to print money.
This content was published on
2 minutes
Urs Geiser, swissinfo.ch
The cabinet recommended voters reject a rightwing initiative which aims to suspend all international treaties considered incompatible with the Swiss constitution, including the European Human Rights Convention.
Approval of the initiative could have serious negative economic and diplomatic consequences, a statement warned.
“It could lead to legal insecurity and damage the Swiss economy,” said a statement published by the justice ministry on Wednesday following the weekly cabinet meeting.
A committee led by the rightwing Swiss People’s Party collected more than 116,000 signatures, forcing a nationwide vote on the issue.
“The Swiss people and cantons must again be the supreme legal authority,” campaigners argue, because parliament, the government and the courts have allegedly been giving priority to “foreign law and foreign judges”.
Human rights organisations have strongly criticised the initiative.
‘Sovereign money’
The cabinet has also rejected a separate initiative by critics of the current monetary system.
“The initiative promises too much and carries unforeseeable risks,” said Finance Minister Ueli Maurer at a news conference.
The proposal is tantamount to “nationalising the monetary system” and jeopardises the independence of the central bank, he continued.
Maurer also warned that a radical change in the Swiss monetary system was unlikely to be successful in a globalised financial system.
For their part, the organisers of the “Sovereign Money” initiative say their proposed reform is aimed at preventing economic crises by creating a more stable banking system.
Their proposal wants to make the Swiss National Bank the sole institution allowed to generate money, including bank deposits, while commercial banks would no longer be able to grant loans.
They also hope Switzerland could be a model for other countries.
Parliament still has to discuss both initiatives before setting a date for each of the proposals to be put to voters for the final say.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here. Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
An attack on human rights or strengthening democracy?
This content was published on
Thanks to direct democracy, the Swiss voting public regularly has the chance to propose or vote on changes to the constitution. But what happens when changes contradict international agreements or laws? A prime example would be the 2014 vote to limit immigration – which directly contradicts the free movement of people agreement between Switzerland and…
International vs national law: a manufactured controversy?
This content was published on
The rightwing Swiss People’s Party is calling for a people’s initiative, saying that “democratically legitimised Swiss law” should take precedent over international law, despite the constitution stating the opposite. But human rights experts say the conflict is artificial.
Legal expert: Switzerland must follow the rules or quit ECHR
This content was published on
Either Switzerland adheres to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and implements the judgments of the Strasbourg Court order or leaves the ECHR and walks away from the Council of Europe – there are no other alternatives, according to a study commissioned by human rights organisations.
This content was published on
Voters are set to have the final say on a proposal by a group of activists to reform Swiss monetary policy and to grant the Swiss National Bank (SNB) the exclusive power to create new money.
This content was published on
At its annual general meeting on Friday, the SNB also dismissed separate plans to expand its governing beyond its current three members and to extend its mandate into stabilising employment and exchange rates. The raft of reform proposals were sparked by the SNB’s failed attempt to peg the franc to the euro from September 2011.…
This content was published on
The 59-year-old political scientist stepped down as director of the leading GfS Bern research and polling institute earlier this year. He will remain chairman until 2019. Longchamp, known to many television viewers as “the man with the bow tie”, has an undeniable expertise of nationwide votes in Switzerland. He talks to swissinfo.ch about direct democracy,…
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here. Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.