(Bloomberg) -- The European Central Bank offered lenders partial relief from its negative interest rates -- cut again on Thursday -- but it wasn’t enough to restore confidence in Europe’s banks, which saw their stocks slide.
The Governing Council is introducing a two-tier system for reserves in which part of banks’ holdings of excess liquidity will be exempt from the ECB’s deposit charges. The ECB also improved the conditions for making long-term loans to banks, known as TLTROs, by lowering the interest rate.
The ECB is betting that further rate cuts will help revive inflation and growth as the threats from U.S. trade protectionism and Brexit hit confidence. Lenders have long complained that the policy, which results in them paying to park their cash with the central bank, squeezes profitability. That could cause them to pare back lending which in turn would drag down growth, creating another headache for the ECB.
“It was overdue that the ECB introduces a tiering system for its negative deposit rate,” Hans-Walter Peters, president of the Association of German Banks, said in a statement. “But this positive step is largely offset by the further reduction of interest rates” and asset purchases.
Bank stocks slid, with the Bloomberg Europe Banks and Financial Services Index down 0.2% as of 3:04 p.m. in Frankfurt. They have declined about 7.5% since late March when ECB President Mario Draghi said the central bank is ready to soften the impact of negative rates if they are found to harm the transmission of its monetary policy. Deutsche Bank AG fell 1.4% and Commerzbank AG lost 1.5%.
Starting Oct. 30, the ECB will split excess liquidity it holds for banks into two brackets and exempt one of them from its minus 0.5% deposit rate. The exempted portion will amount to six times the minimum reserves that a bank is required to hold at the ECB. Both those measures are subject to change, it said.
Exempting some of the deposits from a charge, a process known as tiering, will relieve some of the pressure on profits. At a conference last week, top executives from Deutsche Bank AG, ABN Amro Bank NV and UBS Group AG were among those who called for action.
However, there is concern that such a system would favor financial institutions in places like Germany and France, where deposits tend to outweigh loans, rather than in Italy, where banks are more often net borrowers.
“Its not that we want to protect bank profits” by introducing the tiering relief, Draghi said at a press conference. “Lending goes through banks and we want to protect the transmission of our monetary policy through the lending channels.”
The new system introduced by Draghi in his penultimate policy meeting as ECB president owes a lot to frameworks elsewhere in the world where central banks have opted to cut rates below zero.
The Bank of Japan decided on a tiering system simultaneously with their negative rates policy in January 2016, and began applying it 18 days after its announcement.
The Japanese version of pain relief involves breaking up banks’ deposits into three tiers -- one with a positive rate, one at zero and one that’s negative. Despite the benefit, bankers there still complain that their profits are being squeezed. “There is a limit to what banks can do to cope” with negative rates, Japanese Bankers Association Chairman Makoto Takashima said in July.
The Swiss National Bank is using negative rates to prevent an appreciation of the franc. It operates a two-level system, with amounts equal to 20 times a bank’s minimum reserves exempt from any charge. Above that level, an annualized rate of 0.75% is levied on the deposits held at the central bank.
The negative rate earned the SNB 2 billion francs in income last year. Yet the ultra-low interest rates have fueled a real estate market bonanza that risks overheating, as investors hunt for yield. They’re also very unpopular with banks. Both Credit Suisse Group AG and UBS find themselves having to balance the prospect of losing money with clients’ cash deposits against imposing fees that could prompt customers to jump ship.
UBS decided to charge its Swiss clients an annual 0.6% on deposits of more than 500,000 euros, down from 1 million euros previously, while Credit Suisse has a fee of 0.4% for euro accounts of more than 1 million euros.
(Adds details of tiering plan in sixth paragraph.)
--With assistance from Steven Arons.
To contact the reporters on this story: Nicholas Comfort in Frankfurt at email@example.com;Yuko Takeo in Tokyo at firstname.lastname@example.org;Catherine Bosley in Zurich at email@example.com
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Paul Gordon at firstname.lastname@example.org, ;Dale Crofts at email@example.com, Ross Larsen
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.