Covid-19: Swiss court gives mixed ruling on political gathering limits
The Federal Court, Switzerland’s highest court, on Friday ruled that a 15-person limit on political gatherings in Bern during the pandemic was unconstitutional, but it admitted a limit of 300, introduced by canton Uri.
This content was published on
3 minutes
Keystone-SDA/SRF/jc
The Federal Court was ruling on two appeals concerning anti-coronavirus restrictions introduced by cantons Bern and Uri. It noted that last year’s federal decree introducing coronavirus measures under an “exceptional situation” did not include restrictions on political gatherings. The cantonal limits concerned are no longer in force now.
The Federal Court judges ruled by a majority of 4-1 that canton Bern’s 15-person limit on political gatherings introduced in November 2020 was contrary to freedom of assembly. They thus granted an appeal by several left-wing political parties and organisations.
More
More
Zurich ban on political gatherings deemed unconstitutional
This content was published on
A Zurich court has criticised the canton’s ban on public demonstrations of more than 15 people, which was in place until last month.
The court did not accept canton Bern’s argument that the measure was justified because of the large number of demonstrations that take place in the federal capital. A majority of judges deemed that such a low number was tantamount to a ban on demonstrations. They also stressed the need for public opinions to be heard, especially at a time of crisis. This, they pointed out, was also one of the federal government’s reasons for excluding political gatherings from its exceptional coronavirus measures.
The court discussion centred on proportionality. It admitted a 300-person limit introduced by canton Uri in March 2021, throwing out an appeal against it. The court deemed that this limit fell within the discretion of the cantonal authorities and did not render political gatherings meaningless.
Cantons welcome ruling
Both cantons Bern and Uri welcomed the court ruling. The Bern cantonal government said it confirmed cantons’ right to impose restrictions under the federal law on epidemics, depending on the situation. It reiterated that the 15-person limit had been introduced at a time when the epidemiological situation was “tense and uncertain” and that the obligation to wear masks in public gatherings was often being ignored.
On the other hand, opponents of government coronavirus restrictions called the ruling a “black day for democracy”.
Appellants also generally welcomed the ruling. The Progressive Association of Bern Democratic Jurists said it showed that fundamental rights and the principles of rule of law also apply during crises and that restrictions are only admissible within a clearly established judicial framework. This is a fundamental decision for the future, it added.
More
More
Coronavirus: the situation in Switzerland
This content was published on
An overview of the latest Covid-related information in the Alpine nation.
Swiss authorities announce cost-cutting in asylum sector
This content was published on
The government notably wants to improve integration into the labour force, particularly for people with protection status S.
Various leaders confirm participation at Ukraine peace conference
This content was published on
The presidents of Poland, Finland, and Latvia and the prime ministers of Spain and Belgium will be at the Swiss-hosted talks in mid-June.
This content was published on
In the winter season up to April 2024, railway and cable car operators ferried 3% more visitors compared to the previous winter, and 5% more than the five-year average.
Rhine flooding: Swiss to invest CHF1 billion with Austria
This content was published on
As part of an international agreement with Austria, the Swiss government wants to pump CHF1 billion ($1.1 billion) into flood protection measures along the Rhine over the next three decades.
Swiss government proposes CHF10 million UNRWA donation
This content was published on
After months of debate, Switzerland plans to give CHF10 million ($11 million) to the UN agency this year, rather than the CHF20 million initially foreseen.
Swiss study: insects mainly migrate at midday and dusk
This content was published on
A study led by the Swiss Ornithological Institute in canton Lucerne is helping to better understand the movement patterns of migratory insects.
Red Cross: 22 staff killed in Middle East since October
This content was published on
The Red Cross and Red Crescent network in Gaza and Israel has lost 22 staff members since last October, the Swiss Red Cross (SRC) said on Wednesday.
Dortmund’s Kobel is first Swiss goalie in Champions League final
This content was published on
Borussia Dortmund’s Gregor Kobel has achieved history by becoming the first Swiss goalkeeper to reach a Champion’s League final.
University students in Switzerland join Gaza protest wave
This content was published on
Pro-Palestinian activists occupied university buildings in Lausanne, Geneva and Zurich on Tuesday, widening the protest movement in the Alpine nation.
Thousands demonstrate against Covid-19 restrictions in Lucerne
This content was published on
A demonstration against the restrictions linked to the coronavirus saw several thousand people gather in central Swiss city of Lucerne.
Zurich ban on political gatherings deemed unconstitutional
This content was published on
A Zurich court has criticised the canton's ban on public demonstrations of more than 15 people, which was in place until last month.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.