Activist sentenced for helping rejected asylum seeker
Swiss human rights activist Anni Lanz has lost an appeal against a decision to fine her for having helped a rejected Afghan asylum seeker return from Italy to Switzerland.
This content was published on
2 minutes
Keystone-SDA/dos
العربية
ar
تغريم ناشطة ساعدت طالب لجوء بالدخول إلى سويسرا من إيطاليا
The 73-year-old former head of Solidarité sans frontiersExternal link was first condemned in December 2018 by a local court in Brig, canton Valais, and given a fine of CHF800 ($815).
On Wednesday, she lost her appeal before the cantonal court, who refused her lawyer’s plea that Lanz had acted “purely from humanitarian motivations” in helping an Afghan asylum seeker reenter the country from Italy after an initial rejection by Swiss authorities.
“All violations of the law must be punished,” the judge said.
For the prosecutor, Lanz could have helped the man where he was in Italy, rather than try to bring him back to Switzerland – an argument rejected by the defendant, who said she had tried and failed to find institutions in Milan that would help the Afghan, who suffered from severe post-traumatic stress and who had attempted suicide several times.
Muriel Trummer of Amnesty International Switzerland was at the trial in Sion and said that the ruling was a sad defeat for those who fight for migrant and asylum rights.
“Anni Lanz acted purely from compassion and this ruling is terribly unfair,” she said.
Good intentions
This is not the first such ruling in Switzerland that has raised the issue of how to deal with altruistic motivations in breaching the federal law on foreigners.
Norbert Valley, a priest from the eastern Swiss town of Le Locle, was handed a CHF1,000 fine in August 2018 for helping a rejected Togolese asylum seeker; he has appealed.
And in 2017, a Ticino politician was convicted for having helped immigrants illegally enter Switzerland from Italy and given a fine of CHF8,800.
While some European countries do not prosecute the act of helping illegal immigrants when the intention is honourable (rather than financial), in Switzerland it has been blanketly illegal since 2008.
According to the Federal Statistical Office, 785 people were convicted of such a crime in 2017 alone, though this figure doesn’t distinguish between those acting from humanitarian or financial motivation.
Anni Lanz said on Wednesday that she would examine the judgement in more detail with her lawyer before deciding whether to appeal at the federal level.
Young undocumented migrants gain easier access to vocational training
This content was published on
Rejected asylum-seekers and young undocumented migrants in Switzerland will have easier access to basic vocational training from June 1.
Migration: Swiss government wants to shorten reunification period for families
This content was published on
Family members of people temporarily admitted to Switzerland should in future be able to join them after two years instead of three.
This content was published on
2023 was a record year for the Rhaetian Railway in several respects. Never before has the narrow-gauge railway in Graubünden, eastern Switzerland, transported so many passengers and cars.
Swiss CFOs much more optimistic despite global uncertainty
This content was published on
The main concerns of business leaders in Switzerland are geopolitical uncertainty and the important trading partners Germany and China.
Record organ donation in Switzerland despite high rejection rates
This content was published on
More organ donations were recorded in Switzerland in 2023 than ever before. This was despite a high rejection rate of 58% by surviving relatives.
This content was published on
Seven years after the death of record-breaking Swiss mountain climber Ueli Steck, his estate is going to the Alpine Museum of Switzerland in Bern.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss priest appeals fine for helping asylum seeker
This content was published on
A hearing took place on Thursday to examine the appeal of a Swiss priest against a fine he was handed for sheltering a rejected asylum seeker.
This content was published on
Discussions about immigration are often plagued by the prejudices and presumptions of both sides. A new book attempts to go beyond ‘pro’ vs ‘anti’.
This content was published on
Most asylum proceedings are now to be completed within 140 days in federal asylum seekers’ centres. This compares with an average of 280 days in 2015. The reform was approved by two-thirds of Swiss voters in spring 2016. + Read more about the 2016 vote on accelerated asylum procedures As of March 1, asylum…
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.