Swiss perspectives in 10 languages

Switzerland Combats Counterfeit Cheese With DNA Fingerprints

(Updates with trade balance in 18th paragraph.)

Aug. 27 (Bloomberg) — Swiss cheesemakers’ weapon against forgeries is housed at minus 80 degrees Celsius (minus 112 Fahrenheit) in a Bern freezer. It’s here where scientists keep 10,000 strains of milk bacteria to guard against copycats.

The country’s cheese industry, worth 604 million Swiss francs ($659 million) in exports last year, has turned to DNA fingerprinting to fight counterfeits, which Emmental producers estimate have cost them as much as 20 million francs.

Forgeries are contributing to declining revenue for an industry that’s already beleaguered because of high production costs and the rise in value of the Swiss franc, which makes the country’s cheese more expensive abroad. About 10 percent of cheese labeled as Swiss-made Emmental on supermarket shelves is fake, estimates association Switzerland Cheese Marketing.

“If the cheese is an inferior fake, it ruins the reputation,” said Agnes Beroud, who works for the producers’ association for Tete De Moine, which means Monk’s Head and is served sliced paper thin. “For us, it’s important to protect the traditional way of making the cheese.”

The Swiss have been producing cheese since at least the Middle Ages — with the first medieval mention of it dating to 1115. Today, makers of Emmental, Tete, Gruyere and other varieties must adhere to strict rules to guarantee purity. That raises production costs and means consumers pay a higher price.

Italian Fakes

It also opens the door to cut-rate forgeries falsely claiming to be made in Switzerland according to the country’s stringent standards, and compounds the challenge producers already face from cheeses with Swiss names, such as Emmental, that are legitimately produced elsewhere and cost less.

“We’ve got a big history and it’s important to safeguard it,” said Daniel Amstutz,who runs the family dairy in the hamlet of Fornet-Dessous after taking it over from his father in 1991. His son Menno now oversees production of Tete de Moine, which traces its origins to the nearby medieval monastery of Bellelay. “I hope it continues like this.”

Bacterial fingerprinting started in 2011 with Emmental, the most widely exported Swiss cheese, after fakes surfaced in Italy. Tete de Moine, a round, semi-hard cheese made by only eight dairies in the Jura region, got its marker last year. Identifiers for Gruyere and Sbrinz are in the works.

To reach this point, a team of government scientists worked for a decade to identify the right type of bacteria. The challenge was finding some that wouldn’t alter the taste, texture or smell of Swiss cheese. Using a synthetic identifier wasn’t possible because additives are forbidden. The 10,000 strains in the Bern freezer were harvested decades ago, before the mass-use of antibiotics.

Protective Label

Today, only registered producers may order sachets of the bacteria. The scientists rotate among three DNA markers to ensure that even if a forger gets hold of a packet, it won’t be of much use. There are also spot checks in supermarkets.

“You take the cheese, extract the DNA and check for the presence of your marker,” said Deborah Rollier, one of the lead scientists for the project at Agroscope, the Swiss federal government’s institute for food science in Bern.

Traditional Swiss cheeses always bear the maker’s number and production date, though they’re usually cut into smaller chunks for sale to consumers, obliterating the label. Tete de Moine traditionally is shaved into slivers or rosettes using a device called a Girolle.

To qualify as true Tete, thus receiving a protective label that enables authorities both in Switzerland and the European Union to take legal action against counterfeits, production must be at a dairy located in the Jura, by the French border.

Cheaper Knock-Offs

The milk for Tete may only come from cows within a 20- kilometer (12.4-mile) radius that feed on fresh grass and hay, not fermented stored fodder called silage. Artificial ingredients, including preservatives, are forbidden. The regulations for Emmental and Gruyere are similarly strict.

In 2005, a cheese maker in the Swiss city of St. Gallen was caught with 200 rounds of fake Emmental. Each round weighs about 90 kilograms (198 pounds).

“It has a deterrent effect, because people know there is a method” to catch fakes, said Petra Luedin, a project manager at Agroscope. “Fakes in Italy have declined.”

Taking on counterfeits is one aspect of the industry’s battle for customers, with consumers in recession-plagued Europe often opting for cheaper knock-offs. Emmental exports sank 18 percent in volume terms in the first half of 2014, while the tonnage of exported Tete declined 3.4 percent.

For the first time, Switzerland’s imports of cheese topped exports in June, the newspaper NZZ am Sonntag reports on Aug. 24, citing the industry association.

With 12 employees, Amstutz’s dairy produces roughly 2,000 cheeses a day, working 365 days a year. Most of the tasks — including filling the curd into metal forms and later washing the cheese with saltwater as it ages for three months on spruce shelves — are carried out by hand. The future of that craftsmanship is in danger, Amstutz said.

“If other countries don’t do anything about forgeries, of course we’re powerless,” he said.

–With assistance from Thomas Mulier in Geneva.

To contact the reporter on this story: Catherine Bosley in Zurich at To contact the editors responsible for this story: Fergal O’Brien at Zoe Schneeweiss

Popular Stories

Most Discussed

SWI - a branch of Swiss Broadcasting Corporation SRG SSR

SWI - a branch of Swiss Broadcasting Corporation SRG SSR