It is still unclear whether Swiss Federal Railways new long-distance train, the FV Dosto, is suitable for disabled passengers. The Federal Office of Transport aimed to clarify this question with tests. However, disability organisations are outraged.
In videos obtained by Swiss public television, SRF, a man in a wheelchair tries to get into an FV Dosto. After several attempts and with great difficulty, the wheelchair makes it over the entry ledge. As soon as the man is in the entrance area of the train, he gets up and leaves the train on foot.
For the umbrella organisation of disabled people’s organisations, it is unacceptable that people without impairments check whether a train is suitable for disabled people.
“People with a disability who sit in a wheelchair, unlike people without a disability, do not have certain physical abilities. For example, if the wheelchair is in danger of tipping backwards, they may not be able to simply tilt their upper body forward to keep their balance,” says Caroline Hess-Klein, head of the Equality Department at Inclusion Handicap.
Test results are invalid
In addition, the wheelchairs seen in the videos are unsuitable for public transport travel. They are mainly used in hospitals and homes.
For the umbrella organisation of disabled people’s organisations, it is therefore clear that the test results do not reflect the reality of individuals operating in wheelchairs.
When questioned by SRF, the Federal Office of Transport (FOT) said that the plastic dolls were primarily used for the tests. They stated that this is the only way to objectively and accurately determine how much strength people with disabilities need to be able to get on and off the train independently. The people seen in the videos supplemented the tests: “Here it was a matter of testing the entry and exit with various other body masses and generally getting a feeling for the question.”
For Caroline Hess-Klein of Inclusion Handicap, this procedure shows a fundamental problem: “This means that the FOT, but also other authorities, have not yet understood that you cannot proceed without people with disabilities in order to clarify certain questions that essentially concern the effects on people with disabilities. Only they have certain experiences and insights that can contribute to clarification.”
More
Debate
Hosted by:
Sara Pasino
How can Swiss trains survive low-cost airlines?
Swiss trains are often more expensive than flights. How can they compete with low-cost airlines?
Based on the tests, the FOT must assess whether the FV-Dosto trains are in fact suitable for individuals with disabilities. Hess-Klein has already announced that she will take the matter to the Federal Administrative Court if the FOT answers “yes” to this question.
This news story has been written and carefully fact-checked by an external editorial team. At SWI swissinfo.ch we select the most relevant news for an international audience and use automatic translation tools such as DeepL to translate it into English. Providing you with automatically translated news gives us the time to write more in-depth articles. You can find them here.
If you want to know more about how we work, have a look here, and if you have feedback on this news story please write to english@swissinfo.ch.
External Content
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Almost finished… We need to confirm your email address. To complete the subscription process, please click the link in the email we just sent you.
Popular Stories
More
Climate change
The international consequences of a glacier-free Switzerland
Is your place of origin, your Heimatort, important to you?
Every Swiss citizen has a Heimatort, a place of origin, but many have never visited theirs. What’s your relationship with your Heimatort? What does it mean to you?
What factors should be taken into account when inheriting Swiss citizenship abroad?
Should there be a limit to the passing on of Swiss citizenship? Or is the current practice too strict and it should still be possible to register after the age of 25?
Trains resume service to Swiss ski resort Zermatt after heavy snowfall
This content was published on
Zermatt can once again be reached by train starting Saturday afternoon. The Alpine holiday resort was inaccessible by land for some time after heavy snowfall last Thursday.
Authorities urge vigilance after heavy snowfall in southern Switzerland
This content was published on
Vigilance remains the order of the day in the southern canton of Valais, despite a stable situation after heavy snow on Thursday, authorities said on Saturday.
Switzerland won’t be spared drug violence: criminal police head
This content was published on
It is only a matter of time before Switzerland, like other countries in Europe, experiences an escalation in drug-related violence, says the head of the Federal Criminal Police.
Handful of Swiss Easter processions take place after inclement weather
This content was published on
Traditional Good Friday processions continue to take place in some municipalities in Switzerland. In Romont, canton Fribourg, for example, the "Pleureuses" marched through the streets.
Great St. Bernard pass between Switzerland and Italy closed due to avalanche
This content was published on
An avalanche forced the closure of the Great St. Bernard pass between Switzerland and Italy on Thursday. The route remains closed to Easter traffic.
‘Pressure will increase on Switzerland to invest more in defence’
This content was published on
Markus Mäder, Switzerland's state secretary for security policy, believes that more cooperation is needed in order to strengthen defence in Europe.
Just one in five Swiss attend a religious service at Easter
This content was published on
Only one in five people in Switzerland attend a religious service during the Easter period or give up meat or alcohol for at least one day of fasting. Around 25% of those polled see Easter primarily as a family holiday, according to the survey.
Major road disruptions continue after heavy snowfall in parts of Switzerland
This content was published on
The snowfall has ended in the southern Swiss canton of Valais, the cantonal emergency services said on Friday. Several roads, however, remain closed.
Swiss businessman gets prison term for asbestos deaths
This content was published on
Stephan Schmidheiny has been sentenced to 9 years and 6 months in prison by the Turin Court of Appeal in a case against the former Eternit executive over deaths linked to asbestos exposure in Italy.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss state railways posts loss and plans cost-cutting measures
This content was published on
The state-run railway company says it has a loss of CHF245 million ($266 million) last year despite an increase in passengers.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.