Voters opt for radical measures in anticipation of soft implementation
According to a study, around 6% of Swiss voters approve a people’s initiative that they consider too radical, believing that the government will soften it when it is implemented.
This content was published on
2 minutes
SDA-Keystone/ac
The study published on Thursday was carried out by the Centre for Studies on Democracy External linkin Aarau. It analysed for the first time the prevalence of “compensatory votes” in people’s initiatives on the basis of the Vox analyses from 1993 to 2005.
A people’s initiative allows citizens to put an idea on any topic to national vote, as long as they collect the requisite 100,000 signatures within a period of 18 months. Since 1891, when the idea of the initiative as a way of amending the constitution was introduced, over 400 such initiatives have been launched.
A large number of these never reached the people for a vote, because the required number of signatures were not gathered, or the initiative was withdrawn before voting day.
While 6% were found to vote this way on average, the value varies considerably from one initiative to another. The highest prevalence of compensatory voting was 14.8% (the 1996 people’s initiative against illegal immigration). It had the lowest prevalence in the 2001 people’s initiative to join the European Union (2.2%).
This kind of compensatory voting generally occurs when a voter feels the implementation of the initiative will be decided by bodies (usually parliament and the government) that have hitherto opposed it. Older voters are also more likely to vote this way as they are more likely to have seen an initiative diluted during implementation. Trust in institutions also influences compensatory voting. The less trust a voter has in the government, the more likely they are to vote in this way.
The result of a vote is therefore never the exact reproduction of the “true will of the people”, the study concludes. This situation presents a risk because the legitimacy of decisions in direct democracy is based on the assumption that they reflect the individual political attitudes of voters.
However, compensating voters do not endanger democracy, according to Thomas Milic, co-author of the study. Voters are above all rational beings “who, like chess players, try to anticipate the next steps. Our analysis shows that they are often right.”
More
More
The four ingredients of a successful people’s initiative
This content was published on
The people’s initiative is the fundamental instrument of Swiss direct democracy, but what’s needed to make it successful?
Protein in abdominal fat could help shape obesity treatment
This content was published on
The study analysed fat cells from different locations in the body, and found that those in the abdomen have unique properties.
North African asylum claims fall after rapid Swiss processing
This content was published on
The accelerated procedure, now out of its test phase, has resulted in a significant drop in applications from North African countries.
This content was published on
The artist's song "The Code" focuses on their journey as a nonbinary individual. It is one of the favourites to win this year's contest.
Swiss climate activists block vehicles near Gotthard tunnel
This content was published on
Around ten climate activists briefly blocked the A2 motorway near the northern entrance of the Gotthard tunnel on Thursday.
Watches belonging to Michael Schumacher up for auction
This content was published on
Schumacher's family is auctioning off eight rare watches from his collection in Geneva. The Christie's auction will take place on Monday.
Joya Marleen and Baschi named best solo acts at Swiss Music Awards
This content was published on
St. Gallen singer Joya Marleen and Baschi from Basel were named artists of the year at the Swiss Music Awards 2024 on Wednesday night.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Bizarre or idealistic? Swiss initiatives come in all forms
This content was published on
The Swiss can vote on cow horns, footpaths or even minarets: issues that may seem exotic, attracting worldwide attention.
This content was published on
As a key part of Switzerland’s system of direct democracy, the people’s, or citizen’s initiative allows each member of the Swiss electorate – including those living abroad – to propose a change to the constitution. An initiative can be launched by a single person, but more typically, an interest group collects at least 100,000 signatures.…
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.