Historic verdict could force Swiss re-vote on family tax breaks
The Supreme Court has annulled the result of a controversial nationwide vote about tax breaks for families, paving the way for a re-run of the ballot – a first in the history of Switzerland’s system of direct democracy.
The judges ruled that the government had failed to provide correct information to voters on a proposal to ensure equal tax treatment for married and unmarried couples, according to a Federal Court statement published on Wednesday.
“The incomplete and intransparent information by the government violated the freedom of vote. Keeping in mind the close result and the severe nature of the irregularities, it is possible that the outcome of the ballot could have been different,” the statement said.
Last year, the government admitted the misinformation, saying the number of couples that would be affected was wrongly reported. Instead of the 80,000 married and registered couples that were in line to benefit from reduced taxes, it was 454,000 couples.
In an initial reaction, the centrist party welcomed the verdict and called on the government to improve its information policy. “Today’s decision is a boost for the political rights of Swiss voters,” the party said.
In June 2018, it lodged an appeal against the result, arguing the government’s campaign was based on false statistics.
Critics, however, argue that the court decision could set a precedent for a flood of complaints, undermining direct democracy.
For its part, the government said it had taken note of the ruling and it would consider the next steps when the detailed verdict is published.
Observers say the government and parliament could present a counter-proposal for a legal amendment allowing the initiative committee to withdraw its initiative.
History
For Vincent Martenet, a professor of law at the university of Lausanne, the court verdict is not a surprise. It shows the solid legal basis of Switzerland’s democratic system.
Voters have a right to be informed correctly, Martenet is quoted as saying.
It is the first time in recent Swiss history that the Federal Court ordered an annulment of a nationwide vote result, according to the Federal Chancellery.
In 2008, the highest court rejected a demand to cancel the result of vote on a corporate tax reform, saying a re-run of the ballot would undermine legal security.
However, the Federal Court declared invalid several results from cantonal and local votes over the past 100 years. At a national level, the court was only given right to rule on votes in 2007.
Back in the 19th century, the House of Representatives annulled the result of the 1854 elections in canton TicinoExternal link following reports of violence and voter intimidation.
More
More
Swiss government guilty of repeated miscalculation
This content was published on
For the first time in history, voters may have go back to the polls at the national level to decide for a second time on the same people’s initiative.
Swiss climate activists block vehicles near Gotthard tunnel
This content was published on
Around ten climate activists briefly blocked the A2 motorway near the northern entrance of the Gotthard tunnel on Thursday.
Watches belonging to Michael Schumacher up for auction
This content was published on
Schumacher's family is auctioning off eight rare watches from his collection in Geneva. The Christie's auction will take place on Monday.
Joya Marleen and Baschi named best solo acts at Swiss Music Awards
This content was published on
St. Gallen singer Joya Marleen and Baschi from Basel were named artists of the year at the Swiss Music Awards 2024 on Wednesday night.
Swiss authorities announce cost-cutting in asylum sector
This content was published on
The government notably wants to improve integration into the labour force, particularly for people with protection status S.
Various leaders confirm participation at Ukraine peace conference
This content was published on
The presidents of Poland, Finland, and Latvia and the prime ministers of Spain and Belgium will be at the Swiss-hosted talks in mid-June.
This content was published on
In the winter season up to April 2024, railway and cable car operators ferried 3% more visitors compared to the previous winter, and 5% more than the five-year average.
Rhine flooding: Swiss to invest CHF1 billion with Austria
This content was published on
As part of an international agreement with Austria, the Swiss government wants to pump CHF1 billion ($1.1 billion) into flood protection measures along the Rhine over the next three decades.
Swiss government proposes CHF10 million UNRWA donation
This content was published on
After months of debate, Switzerland plans to give CHF10 million ($11 million) to the UN agency this year, rather than the CHF20 million initially foreseen.
Christian Democrats demand re-run of marriage vote
This content was published on
The party has announced it is seeking a re-run of a 2016 national vote that narrowly rejected the idea of a tax break for married couples.
Government seeks to end ‘unequal’ taxation of married couples
This content was published on
The Swiss government wants to amend tax law to ensure equal fiscal treatment of married couples compared to unmarried cohabitating couples.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.