Organic farming has lower yield but is better for the environment
Organic farming is much better for preserving our environment. It commands higher prices but yields are still much lower than with conventional farming.
Keystone / Jean-christophe Bott
Yields from organic farming are more than 20% lower than with conventional methods, but organic farming is twice as environmentally friendly, a Swiss study has found.
This content was published on
2 minutes
Keystone-SDA/jc
A field that is farmed organically has 230% more plant species diversity than a conventionally cultivated field, according to a studyExternal link published on Thursday by the federal agricultural research institute Agroscope.
For this long-term research, scientists from Agroscope and the University of Zurich looked at the impacts of four different farming systems: conventional farming with and without ploughing; organic farming with ploughing; and organic farming with reduced tillage of the soil.
Researchers found 90% more earthworms in the organic plots and 150% more in the no-till plots. There was less soil erosion in these plots. Ecotoxicity is also 81% lower with methods that do not use pesticides.
“If you look at all the environmental impacts, organic farming is clearly in the lead,” said Marcel van der Heijden, head of the study at Agroscope.
Environmental protection, however, is accompanied by lower yields. On average, yields are 22% lower, and even 34% lower in organic farming with reduced tillage.
In terms of yield, “organic farming still has great potential for improvement”, said Raphaël Wittwer, main author of the study which was published recently in “Science Advances”. This ranges from the selection of resistant varieties to the improvement of biological plant protection and the optimisation of fertilisation.
On the plots, the researchers rotated winter wheat, grain maize, beans and clover. The trial has been running for twelve years and “will continue for at least another six years”, says Agroscope.
Popular Stories
More
Climate adaptation
Why Switzerland is among the ten fastest-warming countries in the world
Has your continent reached its peak or is there still potential for economic growth?
Some regions of the world are on an upward trajectory with the promise of a steadily improving future. Where do you live? And in which direction is your region or continent developing?
A tropical parasite spreads from Switzerland to Germany
This content was published on
A pest from the tropics is giving Swiss agriculture a hard time. The caterpillar of the tomato moth (Helicoverpa armigera) devours almost everything. The moth is now spreading northwards.
Over 10,000 people brave the rain for Geneva Lake Parade
This content was published on
The Lake Parade attracted more than 10,000 people to Geneva on Saturday afternoon in torrential rain. This techno and festive event took place in a reduced format and on an unusual reversed route because of the Women's Euro.
This content was published on
The Zurich cantonal police today arrested two men in Pfungen, a few kilometres from Winterthur (ZH), who were trying to rob a gun shop. Thefts in such businesses in Switzerland have multiplied recently.
This content was published on
Flight safety is reduced by the clogging of airspace, says Thomas Steffen, a pilot for Swiss and head of safety at Aeropers, the industry association.
Malaysian artist Yee I-Lann holds first major European exhibition in Thun
This content was published on
Das Kunstmuseum Thun richtet im August die erste grössere Europaausstellung der malaysischen Künstlerin Yee I-Lann aus. Darin werden Einflüsse des Kolonialismus aber auch das Fortbestehen des indigenen Erbes thematisiert.
Data from Swiss health foundation Radix leaked on the dark web
This content was published on
After the cyber attack suffered by the Radix foundation at the end of last month, sensitive personal data such as names and debts of people banned from casinos were published on the Darknet.
This content was published on
Companies with an externally validated net-zero target emit less CO2 than those without a climate target. This is the conclusion of a new analysis by the US financial services provider MSCI.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss consumers attracted by organic food
This content was published on
Organic products continue to increase their share of the retail market in Switzerland, according to the Bio Suisse organisation.
This content was published on
Organic food continues to attract Swiss consumers, who spent CHF360 per person on such produce in 2018, up from CHF320 the previous year.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.