Former Swiss minister regrets fuss about hostage ransom comments
Moritz Leuenberger in 2010.
Keystone / Lukas Lehmann
Former Swiss minister Moritz Leuenberger triggered outrage on Sunday when he said that “if a hostage has been released, a payment has probably been made”. He has now rowed back on his comments, blaming clumsy wording by a newspaper, which he nevertheless approved.
This content was published on
3 minutes
swissinfo.ch/Keystone-SDA/ts/dos
العربية
ar
وزير سويسري سابق يأسف للضجة التي أثارتها تعليقاته بشأن فدية الرهائن
He maintained, however, that “something might have flowed through other channels” and in his opinion it is a “legitimate lie” for the government to deny this.
Leuenberger, a government minister from 1995 to 2010, made the “taboo-breaking” admission in an interviewExternal link with the NZZ am Sonntag which was focused on the idea of lying and untruths in the political and personal sphere.
Asked if he had ever not told the truth as a politician, Leuenberger said the standard denial made by Swiss authorities of having paid ransoms to release hostages was more about “preventing imitators and future hostage-taking” than it was the truth.
“If you explain this behaviour to the public, it’s accepted as a legitimate lie,” he said, before adding that untruths have a place in society as “social lubricants that help protect the interests of other parties”.
“Always sticking to the truth can sometime cause more problems than telling an untruth,” said Leuenberger, now 74 and retired.
‘Clumsy’
Although Leuenberger had made a similar argument in a book he wrote in 2007, his comments on Sunday triggered a wave of criticism, with many politicians and security experts saying he was undermining the credibility of Switzerland’s hostage policy.
More
More
Ex-hostage could face massive bill
This content was published on
However, the government has revealed that its SFr300,000 ($275,000) budget for “consular protection” has been drained by recent kidnappings and it is discussing whether hostages or tour operators should pay for the “supplementary loan”. Greiner’s case has also raised the issues of self-responsibility and of kidnap and ransom insurance. “This operation obviously cost more than…
Officially, the Swiss foreign ministry has always claimed that Switzerland does not pay ransom demands to free hostages, although rumours have circulated for a long time that this is not true.
“Switzerland’s position remains the same: it does not pay ransom money,” insisted a spokesman for the foreign ministry on Monday.
When confronted with this criticism, Leuenberger said: “I attribute the strong reactions to the summary on the front page of the NZZ am Sonntag and to a formulation in the written version.” Although he had approved it, in retrospect he considered it clumsy.
He added that, to his knowledge, no ransom payments were ever decided in government during his term of office. “But sometimes it can be assumed that something might have flowed through other channels. Nevertheless, the government denies this. In my opinion that is a legitimate lie. And that is precisely my key message.”
Popular Stories
More
Climate adaptation
Why Switzerland is among the ten fastest-warming countries in the world
Is your place of origin, your Heimatort, important to you?
Every Swiss citizen has a Heimatort, a place of origin, but many have never visited theirs. What’s your relationship with your Heimatort? What does it mean to you?
Switzerland is Europe’s most innovative country, EU study finds
This content was published on
In the European Commission's annual ranking, the Swiss score dropped slightly in 2025, but not enough to cost it top spot.
Women’s Euro 2025 has been largely peaceful so far
This content was published on
After two weeks of football fever in various Swiss host cities, no major incidents have been reported so far, police say.
Planned solar park at Bern airport scaled back after talks
This content was published on
The ground-mounted plant at Belpmoos Airport will be smaller than originally planned, the parties involved said on Tuesday.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Freed hostage back on Swiss soil
This content was published on
Werner Greiner, 57, flew into Zurich airport at 11.30am on Tuesday together with his wife, Gabriella, who had also been abducted in January but was released three months later. Switzerland has denied paying a ransom to free the couple. Greiner appeared exhausted, but was relaxed when he spoke to the media alongside his wife and…
This content was published on
A Swiss citizen who had been held by Colombian hostage takers for almost three months has been freed, the Swiss authorities have confirmed.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.