Skiplink Navigation

Main Features

Opinion The two tales of ‘Scotalonia’

External Content

Point of view tag

By Bruno Kaufmann

Two old European nations are about to decide their statehood. While the Scots are addressing the issues linked to independence, the Catalans have to struggle for their right to vote on independence, writes Bruno Kaufmann, editor-in-chief of

Bruno Kaufmann serves as Chairman of the Democracy Council and Election Commission in Falun, Sweden; and is president of the Initiative and Referendum Institute Europe and co-chair of the Global Forum on Modern Direct Democracy. He is the correspondent for Northern Europe at the Swiss Broadcasting Corporation and Editor-in-Chief of, a direct democracy platform created and hosted by

(Bruno Kaufmann)

It happened in the dying minutes of the last televised Scottish independence debate on September 3: actress and pro-independence activist Elaine Smith suddenly burst out laughing.

“What did you say?”, she asked her opponent, Kezia Dugdale, Labour’s Member of the Scottish Parliament. “Did you say that we should have a national conversation on Scotland’s future?”, asked Smith incredulously.

Seconds earlier, Dugdale had proposed that after the September 18 referendum the people of Scotland should start to discuss the “real problems again, like social welfare, health and infrastructure”. 

Britain's Labour leader Ed Miliband campaigns for the NO vote in the Scottish independence referendum


With the historic popular vote coming up on September 18, thousands of documents and studies have been published on the pros and cons of leaving the United Kingdom. Hundreds of thousands of debates and conversations have been held. And almost everybody agrees that this referendum campaign has been a good example for other countries of how to organise a free and fair deliberation and decision-making process. To me this is a positive and encouraging surprise.

But there is another story to tell in Europe – and in the imaginary country of Scotalonia’. It is the story of the people of Catalonia.

A majority of Catalans believe a planned independence vote in November should not go ahead if, as expected, the referendum is declared illegal, two polls showed on September 7


While the campaign tries to underline the normality of this popular independence vote, some people , like Mariano Rajoy, Spain’s prime minister, do not appreciate this kind of normality.

The leader of the conservative People's party has described the independence referendum as ”illegal’ and he is not alone. On April 8, a majority of the members of the Spanish parliament – including the Socialist opposition – voted against an agreement for a decisive popular vote in Catalonia, leaving the region of 7.5 million residents with the only one option left – to call for a consultative vote.

The Catalan parliament is currently finalising its work to establish a new legislation for a consultative vote. Catalan political parties are planning a massive public meeting on September 11, Catalonia’s national day of celebrations – urging millions of citizens to gather in the capital Barcelona. But will anybody listen in Madrid? To me this is a negative and discouraging surprise.

And yet the two tales of Scotalonia offer interesting insights into the options and limits of modern direct democracy in Europe. They tell us that history matters - a lot.

While there appear to be many similarities between Catalonia’s moves to autonomy in 1979 and the referendums for devolution in 1997 (Scotland) and 2006 (Catalonia), the recent monarchic reflexes have been very different in the north and south of Europe.

The UK has been a stable parliamentary monarchy for centuries, while Spain was run by a dictator until the mid-1970s. Beyond Scotalonia, this major difference also became apparent in the way they dealt with violent secessionist movements, such as in Northern Ireland (finally settled by a referendum in 1998) and the Basque Country (where a ceasefire has just been reached).

It is obvious that stable parliamentary rule and experiences with successful settlements of violent conflicts offer a more welcoming context to popular votes than open wounds from dictatorship and unresolved civil wars.

However, history is not limited to the past. It is written today. With the upcoming independence referendums the Scots and (probably also) the Catalans are about to write such modern history – for the benefit of people power and many similar conversations ahead.

Opinion series publishes op-ed articles by contributors writing on a wide range of topics – Swiss issues or those that impact Switzerland. Over time, the selection of articles will present a diversity of opinions designed to enrich the debate on the issues discussed.

end of infobox


Neuer Inhalt

Horizontal Line

SWI on Instagram

SWI on Instagram

SWI on Instagram

subscription form

Form for signing up for free newsletter.

Sign up for our free newsletters and get the top stories delivered to your inbox.

Click here to see more newsletters