Swiss perspectives in 10 languages

Should cows be fed additives to reduce the climate change impact of livestock farming?

Hosted by: Anand Chandrasekhar

Food companies are trying to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by getting suppliers to give their cows special methane-reducing feed. Would you be okay with consuming these meat and dairy products, or would you want more information to decide?

More

Join the conversation!

Contributions must adhere to our guidelines. If you have questions or wish to suggest other ideas for debates, please, get in touch!
OCRAM
OCRAM
The following contribution has been automatically translated from IT.

At first reading I had to laugh: 'Look at that, even the serious Swissinfo.ch is getting into humour'! Then I saw that someone like Nestlé is serious. Obviously it has sniffed out the bargain: to give itself a 'green' and 'Methanfree' guise to appease the Greens and the climate extremist-hysterics, they are studying chemical stuff to add to the food of the dairy herbivores (grass and hay + vattelapesca).
I am more concerned about these chemical additions altering the normal digestive process of our cattle than the methane emitted by their farts and belches. Perhaps some here, business aside, have lost their sense of reality, now taking it out on the poor cattle to improve the global climate. Obviously, I am against these chemical gimmicks that serve no purpose except to increase Nestlé's business in search of a hypocritical 'green' guise.

A prima lettura mi è venuto da ridere: "Ma tu guarda, persino la seriosa Swissinfo.ch si è messa a fare dell'umorismo" ! Poi ho ho visto che qualcuno come la Nestlé fa sul serio. Ovviamente ha fiutato l'affare: per darsi una veste "green" e "Methanfree" per tranquillizzare i Verdi e gli estremisti-isterici climatici, stanno studiando roba chimica da aggiungere al cibo degli erbivori lattiferi (erba e fieno + vattelapesca).
Mi preoccupano di più queste aggiunte chimiche che alterano il normale processo digestivo dei nostri bovini, che non il metano emesso dai loro peti e rutti. Forse qualcuno qui, affari a parte, ha perso il senso della realtà, prendendosela ora con i poveri bovini per migliorare il clima globale. Ovviamente sono contrario a queste trovate chimiche che non servono a nulla, se non ad aumentare il giro d' affari della Nestlé alla ricerca di un'ipocrita veste "green".

Il_don
Il_don

If producing our food and if even animals are now considered a nuisance because they generate climate change, then maybe at that point it is worth starting to consider that climate change is a natural thing that is linked to our destiny. Then we should adapt rather to fight it. What is more crazy: starting to produce food in laboratories using chemicals, engineering and electricity and giving chemicals to cows and pork for they dont fart or adapting ourselves to climate change? I think many governments and a significant part of the scientific community overestimate their understanding of how the world functions, they think that they come with solutions to fix climate change but i think it may in the end make things worse.

Anand Chandrasekhar
Anand Chandrasekhar SWI SWISSINFO.CH
@Il_don

Interesting point. Do you think we should simply accept methane from cows and try to invest our resources on adapting to climate change instead?

SWI swissinfo.ch - a branch of Swiss Broadcasting Corporation SRG SSR

SWI swissinfo.ch - a branch of Swiss Broadcasting Corporation SRG SSR